Did I write something incorrectly? Tell me, please.
Three years ago, I was learning how to play the violin for six months, but when I stopped learning, I forgot everything I had been learned, and now I can't play any musical instrument.
or
I learned how to play the violin for six months, but I forgot everything learned, and now I can't play any instruments.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 4
1
US:
I took/studied violin for six months, but I forgot everything I learned and now I can't play any musical instruments.
or
I had taken/had studied violin for six months, but I have forgotten everything I learned and now I can't play any instruments.
1
The first sentence is definitely too long and has too many clauses. Regardless of the errors inside, it should be split into separate sentences.
The past tense construction 'I was doing X when Y' implies that Y interrupts or stops the action X. Especially as we are describing a fixed amount of time, it's unnatural here. We should use simple past, and possibly change the verb ('I practiced playing the violin for six months'), as the past tense of 'learn' can suggest that we did learn the thing we were trying to learn.
'I had been learned' is incorrect. It means that someone is doing the learning to you. I know that some languages are structured this way, but not English. Use either 'I had been taught', or 'I had learned'.
'can't play any musical instrument' is technically correct, but more natural is '... instruments'.
We might write:
"Three years ago, I started learning how to play the violin for six months. When I stopped learning, I forgot everything I had learned. Now, I can't play any instruments.'
The second sentence has some similar conjugation problems. A simple rewrite is:
"I learned how to play the violin for six months, but I forgot everything I had learned, and now I can't play any instruments".
We should be a little careful with how we order a sentence of the form:
"I learned <verb> for <time>"
Consider the sentences:
"I learned how to hold my breath for three minutes"
"I learned how to play the violin for six months"
Notice that we read them as:
"I learned how to <hold my breath for three minutes>"
"I learned how to <play the violin> <for six months>"
Importantly: we don't know if the time period is attached to the thing that we're learning, or the act of learning itself. We can rewrite the sentence as:
"For six months, I learned how to play the violin."
Which can help sometimes.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
