Search from various English teachers...
Japan flagyaya42
Is it a joke or not? I'm reading a book called "Dogs Don't Tell Jokes (Louis Sachar)". In the book, some junior-high-school students took part in a talent show. Matt, on of the participant, told jokes in the show. I don't understand the introduction of Matt's routine. It goes like this. A teacher: Matt will now tell us some of his favorite jokes. Matt: Well, they're not my "favorites", I can't say "my favorites". * the words between quotation marks are written as italic face. After Matt said it, several people laughed. Is it funny? Is it even a joke or not?

Answers · 8

3
I believe he's implying that his favorite jokes are not suitable to be told in front of his junior high school teacher....
1
I'm not finding it easy to figure out what was meant there, even after having read the passage in the book (on Google Books). If Matt has written the jokes himself then he might consider it immodest to describe any joke that he's invented himself as his "favorite". In fact, his favorite jokes are probably ones written by professional comedy writers. And remember that probably over 99% of the laughs that have ever been laughed are laughed for social reasons and are little, if anything to do with humor. People laugh to make other people feel comfortable, or to show understanding and agreement. It's actually statistically rare for a laugh to be stimulated by something genuinely funny. So I'd expect the audience to be laughing for that reason in this case.
0
Thank you all! I'm sorry, it seemed that the context was not enough. But thanks to all of you, I feel like my English joke skill is improved.
0
I agree with Phil and Steve. It would depend on how it was stressed, but it probably means that he isn't able to tell the jokes that are actually his favourite ones. This is because they are too vulgar to be told in school.
0
I am not sure of the overall meaning of the joke, but I will try to explain ways in which it could be viewed as funny. He could be saying "they're not my 'favorites', I can't say my 'favorites'" because they actually are his favorite jokes and other people know this (which is why the audience laughs). So what he is saying is ironic. He could also mean it literally (that they aren't his favorites), but he may be implying that they are good (which is why he is telling them) and implies this to the audience. (This second theory is a stretch). Perhaps if you provided more source material I could be of better help. Let me know if this helped at all and feel free to ask me if you need any more help.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today