Search from various English teachers...
China flagLily
How do we use but, and? When use adj to describe a city/a country, how do we use and, but? Shanghai is a big and expensive city. Shanghai is a big but expensive city. Seoul is a big and safe city. Seoul is a big but safe city. Which is right? or they are all okay and mean different things.

Answers · 2

1
You use "but" to contrast items. Therefore, "big but safe city" is correct but "big but expensive" isn't. People don't expect a big city to be safe, so using "but" here creates a contrast between the two adjectives. However, big cities are usually expensive as well, so there is no contrast; we expect big cities to be expensive. " Big but inexpensive city" would use "but" effectively. "And" is used in this particular way to link two complimentary or similar descriptions together. "Big and expensive" is correct because, as mentioned above, people expect big cities to be expensive. However "big and safe" doesn't make as much sense because most people don't think that big cities are also safe. Another example is using "young" and "experienced" in a sentence. Most people would say "she is young but experienced" because they're linking two contrasting ideas. To use and, most people would say "she is young and inexperienced" because those two adjectives go together. People don't think that a very young person has a lot of work or life experience.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today