Search from various English teachers...
Japan flagsimizu.norio
the or a In Japanese school they teach that play a piano is wrong, that it should be played the piano. However, I have an impression that as an answer to a question "What did he play at the concert?", "He played a piano" is possible and even more natural than "He played the piano". Am I wrong?

Answers · 3

0
Thanks for your answers. Please allow me to clarify my point: If someone asks,"What did you buy at that music shop?", you could say, "I bought a violin", meaning "I bought, not a guitar or a flute, but a violin." In this case no further explanation about the violin is required, is it? On the contrary, if you say, "I bought the violin", the one who asked would say, "The violin? Which violin? You never mentioned that violin before." In the same manner, I thought, if someone asks "What did you play at the concert?", you could say, "I played a violin", meaning "I played, not a guitar or a flute, but a violin."
0
There is a difference between 'play the piano' and 'play a piano'. When we say, for example, 'My sister's a musician, she plays the piano' or 'I play the piano in my spare time', we are talking about the activity or art form. In this case, we are not referring to the physical instrument, but to the act of making music in a particular way. It is also possible to use a zero article for this purpose. If you say 'a piano', this refers to one individual object. For example, you could say 'I went to an instrument shop and I played a piano that was worth several million pounds'. In this case you are referring to one individual piano, as opposed to any other piano. As for your question about whether you can answer 'What did he do at the concert?' by saying 'He played a piano' - well, you could, but it would be a little strange. It would be drawing attention to a particular wooden object with keys and strings, rather than to the act of playing. The normal response to this question would be 'He played the piano', because this would be telling you about the person's role in the orchestra and the part he played in the performance. Are you wrong in thinking that 'He played a piano' is the more natural answer? Yes, I'm afraid you are. It would be an odd response to make. The listener would think 'A piano? Which piano? ' The listener would be expecting you to explain why you were emphasising the object itself, and might expect you to go on to say 'He played a piano that had the most beautiful tone I've ever heard' or 'He played a piano that sounded like it was about to fall apart any moment' or 'He played a piano that clearly hadn't been tuned in years.'
0
That's a good question. My instinctive response would be "the" or zero ("played piano"). "The" is correct for a different reason to the use of "the" in: "I can play the piano". You said "the concert", and so we assume shared knowledge that there was a piano, just one piano, in the orchestra or band. So in this case, he played "the only" piano. If one person did not know what was in the orchestra or band, this conversation could happen: What instruments were there? There was a piano.... This is new information introduced with "there is", and I imagine you know about this rule.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today