A question about Queen Elizabeth II
I saw the following sentence on Wikipedia today. Wouldn’t the sentence imply that UK, Canada, and Australia in fact were and still are the same country under one person? Why would UK, Canada, and Australia have the same queen but remain separate countries?
“Elizabeth II (Elizabeth Alexandra Mary; born 21 April 1926) is, and has been since her accession in 1952, Queen of the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand, and Head of the Commonwealth.”
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_II
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 15
3
This is for Australia. I'm assuming it's the same or similar for Canada and New Zealand.
The Australian states were colonies directly controlled by the UK up until 1901, when the colonies (except New Zealand, which was considered an Australian colony prior to the existance of Australia as a country) came together and formed a country.
While the Queen is Australia's head of state, we have our own government and economy independent from that of the UK. The prime minister of the UK has no power in Australia and vice-versa.
The Queen's representative in Australia is the Governor-General.
The Statute of Westminster (1931) also gave the Commonwealth countries a significant amount of autonomy. It took away the power of the UK parliament to pass laws in the Commonwealth countries. For example, if the UK went to war with a country, Australia wouldn't be obliged to join them. Conversely, Australia is allowed to fight wars independently of the UK.
Keep in mind the Queen wields very little nowadays. She's very rich, but otherwise she exists mostly as a figurehead.
Edit: I don't know what I was thinking when I wrote "This is is it is...".
2
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_union
2
The situation may be clearer if we consider a different kind of ruler: an emperor (or empress). We understand that an "emperor" may be the ruler of many different nations or countries.
I'm a U.S. native and on shaky ground talking about Britain, but I'll make a guess.
Queen Victoria was both "queen of England" and "empress of India." There was a British Empire long before India was incorporated into it, and the queen or king of England was also the direct ruler of other countries, colonies, and territories, but for whatever reason, the words "emperor" and "empress" were not used until India was added to the empire. Even then, I think (Brits correct me if I'm wrong) she was "Empress" of India but remained "Queen" of everything else?
So, the British had a tradition of being ruled by a king or queen who was really an emperor or empress, but was called simply "king" or "queen." This tradition carried over when the territories of the British Empire became British Commonwealth of Nations.
1
To add to Jmat, think of it this way: a country can democratically choose whomever it wants to be its president or head of state, even if the person chosen is already head of state of another country. This is the case for Queen Elizabeth.
Some heads of state have only ceremonial functions (like Queen Elizabeth) and are usually appointed or approved by elected politicians. Other heads of state are political appointments, and some of these are elected directly by the people (e.g. Presidents Hollande and Obama).
0
Thank Grant for the interesting link! But…, what does it have to do with the question?
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
