With or without S in sentences with relative pronouns
I have trouble with the grammar in sentences with relative pronouns like the following:
I am a girl who like(s) to learn languages.
Should the 's' be there or not? 'Who' makes it third person but also refers to 'I' which is first person.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 6
1
Think of it this way: "I am a girl. The girl likeS to learn languages." The pronoun "who" stands in for "the girl" and binds the two clauses together.
0
General rule: Who will be closest to the noun it represents.
0
I am a girl who likes to learn languages.
You are a girl who likes to learn languages.
Mary is a girl who likes to learn languages.
BUT....
We are girls who like to learn languages.
You are girls who like to learn languages. <--- you plural
They are girls who like to learn languages.
The relative clause is modifying "girls" in these last three sentences, so you need to use the 3rd person plural form of the verb instead. I hope that helps :)
0
Thanks guys! I got confused because I thought of it as 'who' referring to 'I', not 'a girl', but now I see :)
0
The clause "who likes to learn languages" describes "a girl", so it has to have the -s, because the verb must always agree with the noun the clause is describing. "Who" is a relative pronoun actually, and as a pronoun refers to another noun, in this case, a girl. Also remember that as a relative clause, it's an adjective. Always think of what it's referring to. I hope this helps.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
