Search from various English teachers...
Saudi Arabia flagAlanoud
Past simple or present perfect? 1. Alanoud who was studying in the SDF school (had )to paint a picture every day, so she (developed) her drawing skills and (became)an excellent artist. Here is it right to use past simple or it is better with present perfect? 2. they will go to the garden and not watch )TV. Here can I put not with a verb like this?

Answers · 7

1
1) --> both past simple or present perfect would be grammatically correct, but mean slightly different things. In the case of past simple, the subject is farther away, either has died, or you're telling a story of something that happened in the past. Probably in this case it makes more sense to have the first two paint/developed in past simple and the third one (become) on either past simple or present perfect depending on what has happened to Alanoud. Is he alive? Are you talking to him in present? Is there connection? If he's still alive and what you're telling is relevant and close, maybe has become is better. 2) I like the suggestion from James.
1
1 is good, but you need commas to set off your relative clause. 2 depends on what you are trying to say, but consider "They will go into the garden rather than watch TV".
1
Both sentences sound natural to me with what you've got in ().
0
1, Alanoud, who was studying in the SDF school, had to paint a picture every day, so she developed her drawing skills and became an excellent artist. (All must be past tense.) 2. They will go to the garden instead of watching TV. (Gardens don't have TVs.)

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today