Search from various English teachers...
Ali
im confused about a dialogue in "Eyes Wide Shut" , Please Help :) 1st Person : How about a drink ? 2nd Person : Are you having one ? 1st Person : Sure . why they use "having" ?

Answers · 13

1
Being aware of the fact that this question has popped up to your mind from a dialogue in the movie Eyes Wide Shut, please allow me to notify the people commenting and answering your question that the first person answers the second person's question with a "Sure" while it is quiet obvious he wasn't having a drink and he was just pocketing some ball into holes on a billiard table. so we can't say that by asking "Are you having one?" he meant to ask "Are you drinking a drink ?(!)". [watch the movie and you will find out what I'm saying more easily.go to Eyes wide shut [02:11:00]]
1
Present continuous for a definite short-term plan. 'I'm having a coke. What are you having?' This is your definite intention.
1
Sorry, got confused. Yes, it's about what you're going to do right now. That's why present continious.
0
thank you every body for your kindly answers and comments :) i just guess maybe the Reza's answer is the nearest one , maybe ! so i want you to guide me again according to Reza's answer .... many thanks
0
Being aware of the fact that this question has popped up to your mind from a dialogue in the movie Eyes Wide Shut, please allow me to notify the people commenting and answering your question that the first person answers the second person's question with a "Sure" while it is quiet obvious he wasn't having a drink and he was just pocketing some ball into holes on a billiard table. so we can't say that by asking "Are you having one?" he meant to ask "Are you drinking a drink ?(!)". [watch the movie and you will find out what I'm saying more easily.go to Eyes wide shut [02:11:00]]

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today