Why is this sentence wrong?
I did an English exercise, like below,
Could you please tell me ______ your oral English?
I gave the answer "how do you improve"
But it shows that the answer is wrong, and the right one is "how you improved"
Why??? I really don't know why?
Any native speakers can give me an explanation? Thank you beforehand!
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 2
1
You would need a comma.
"do/did" makes the phrase "how you improved you oral English" into something that can stand
alone as a question sentence. If you put another phrase in front of it, you need to separate it from
the question "sentence" with a comma.
(By the way, there is nothing about the textbook question that tells you whether to use past or present tense.)
Compare: (I'm using past tense like your book's answer):
"how you improved your oral English?" <--- not a complete sentence!!
"How did you improve your oral English?" <--- a complete sentence!
"Tell me, how did you improve your oral English?" <--- the phrase at the beginning must be separated by a comma (or pause, in speech). It is almost like they are two sentences: "Tell me. How..."
Without the comma, you can make the entire thing one sentence:
Tell me how you improved your oral English. (A complete sentence, but it is not a question but a command, though it is not rude.)
Could you tell me how you improved your oral English? (A complete sentence, but now it is a polite request, i.e. question.)
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
