Search from various English teachers...
China flagMike
How to use "~+which" in clause There are many kinds of "~+which" in clause. For example: for which; in which; during which; of which and etc. Would like to help me explain these? Best to have sentence!!! Thank you very much!Thank for Getulio's explanation. I want to know more about the different among the "for which; in which; during which; of which and etc" For example: (1) Tomorrow I will bring here a magazine (that/which) you asked for.    = Tomorrow I will bring here a magazine for which you asked.    (2) I have a dresser in my bedroom, which there are many cosmetics on. = I have a dresser in my bedroom on which there are many cosmetics.

Answers · 4

1
Hello Mike, First of all you can use 'which' in 2 types of clauses - defining and non-defining. These clauses are a little like adjectives in that they give you more information about the thing which is being talked about. A defining clause must be present because it tells you exactly which thing and does not appear with commas. A non-defining clause is used with commas and can be removed as it only give additional information, not essential information. In a defining relative clause (only) you can also use 'that' instead of 'which'. You would use prepositions with 'which', generally only in defining clauses to denote 'position'. This is the book in which I found the answer. There is a dresser in my room which there are many things on. - You could use on which but it is very formal and doesn't sound very natural when speaking. If is often more natural to put the preposition at the end. "That is the school I which went to." In some cases you can actually leave out the relative pronoun 'which' as it is obvious - the pronoun is referring to the object of the clause. In the example I just gave - 'This is the school which I went to.' 'which ' refers to the school and 'the school' is the object of the sentence 'I went to the school'. In this instance we can omit the 'which' - 'This is the school I went to.' is a perfect sentence to. Other prepositions like 'during' -referring to time - need to stay in front of 'which'. I hope this is clear for you now. Bob
1
Hey my friend let me see if I can help you: Which, like that, refers to things, but a further consideration is that American English usage usually frowns on this word when it appears in a restrictive, or essential, clause, such as “I chose the card which is blank.” This sentence, which specifies a card among one or more others that are not blank, has a meaning distinct from “I chose the card, which is blank,” which refers to a single card and then describes it. (This is an example of a nonrestrictive, or nonessential, clause.) To further clarify that distinction, the restrictive form is generally illustrated by using that in favor of which, which is reserved for a nonrestrictive function, as in the preceding phrase. (One exception occurs when which is preceded by another usage of that, as in the sentence “What is good is that which is natural.”) (This form is sometimes called nonessential because the information that follows which is not required. In the first sample sentence, which is better rendered “I chose the card that is blank,” the card’s blank state is essential to the context. In “I chose the card, which is blank,” all we need to know is that the card was chosen; its quality of blankness is incidental.) Many writers and speakers of American English deplore the artificial distinction of favoring that over which in restrictive usage, but it is practical and well established — two valid criteria for any variation in purely logical grammar.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today