Search from various English teachers...
China flagsidney
Why a prep word is needed only in sentence 2? 1. My grandma forgot the city she was born. 2. My grandma forgot the day she was born on. Messy Christmas, buddy! Thx!

Answers · 12

3
Hi Sidney As Judy explained, sentence 1 is ungrammatical: You have two pieces of information in this sentence without any connection: 'My grandma forgot the city' and 'she was born'. You have a few options here: use a relative pronoun 'where' to attach 'she was born' to the noun (city) it is modifying - 'My grandma forgot the city where she was born', use the more formal 'in which' - 'My grandma forgot the city in which she was born', or the preposition 'in' at the end - 'My grandma forgot the city she was born in'. Sentence 2 is grammatical, but there is another problem: you need to be clear about what she forgot (the experiences of the day (as Judy explained) or the date). Adding the preposition 'on' to the end of the sentence makes the meaning of 'date' clear. You could also use: 'My grandma cannot remember her birth date (or date of birth)' or the more formal 'My grandma forgot the date on which she was born'. Hope this helps :)
1
It's not 'needed'. The 'on' is optional, as would be 'in' at the end of '1'.
1
Here, #2 would be ok, but #1 should have "in" added to the end. If you say "My grandma forgot the day she was born" it means she can't remember what she experienced on the day she was born."

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today