when to use ING and PAST
Hi people! My question is: if the direct object of a verb is playing an action, must we writte it in gerund or in past? for example:
-I saw Peter opening the door.
-I saw Peter open the door.
Is there any different in meaning? maybe in context? It depends if your English is Brittish or American? Inform me as much as you know, thank you in advance!
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 5
2
There is a slight difference, and the distinction is the same in British and American English. GB and US English aren't as different from each other as some people think!
As Ed says, it can indicate whether you see the complete action or just part of an action in progress.
Let's say a box of chocolates has disappeared. If you say 'I saw Mary eat the chocolates' it means that you saw the entire event and you know that Mary ate them all. But if you say 'I saw Mary eating the chocolates' you maybe passed through a room while she was eating the chocolates, but you don't know if she ate all of them.
2
Personally, I'd have to work hard to draw any difference in common usage. In both cases you are saying you witnessed the action of the door opening.
If there is any difference, it would be that "I saw Peter open the door" confirms that he completed the action, while " I saw Peter opening the door" could mean you saw the action in the midst of it happening, but maybe he didn't complete it.
This distinction would only be relevant in cases where precision might be needed, such as giving testimony in court about what you actually witnessed.
1
Ing is used to express continuous tense.
Opening means - Opening right now or then.
In english language , only one verb can be used in a simple sentence.so the second verb open took gerund ing.
this meaning is same everywhere.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
