Search from various English teachers...
China flagElfreda_Z
which sentence is right? Not a single book he read that month. Not a single book did he read that month. Not a single book had he read that month.

Answers · 4

0
Not a single book did he read that month.
0
The first example is not a full sentence, it's only a fragment, so I would rule that one out... You could say "Not a single book he read that month was worth reading", but the fragment implies that he did read several books, and you are referring to each of them in turn. The second two are both correct but convey slightly different meanings. "Not a single book did he read that month" implies that he didn't read any books at all during the month, and maybe he usually reads many books each month. "Not a single book had he read that month" might mean the same as the one above, or it could also mean that he was looking through a whole pile of books that he might or might not have read in the past, but he certainly had not read any of them during the month in question. Without having the full context of what you wanted to say, I would say that the most natural sounding sentence would be the second one.
0
The second one is the only complete statement. The others could be part of another statement, but the use of 'have/had' implies that you are going to say something about the books that he read that month, that you are not saying. I have included examples of what that might look like. Not a single book he read that month (was still in his room). Not a single book did he read that month. [correct] (i was familiar with) Not a single book (that) had he read that month.
0
"Not a single book did he read that month" and "Not a single book had he read that month" are both correct. They are very similar. The first one implies that the month is over, while the second sentence implies that while he has not read a book that month yet, he still might. The best way of saying this though is, "He did not read a single book that month." Generally, we will put the subject at the front in English.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today