Which sentence is correct and why?
You use the present perfect without saying an exact time, but if an exact time is given you have to use simple past.
Now, I have a problem with the concrete meaning of "exact". I understand that "In the year 2007" is exact, but what about sentences like:
1a) I've first played the guitar when I was a teenager.
1b) I first played the guitar when I was a teenager.
or
2a) When you worked in Hollywood have you ever met anyone famous?
2b) When you worked in Hollywood did you ever meet anyone famous?
Here you don't have an exact date or day of a week but another period of time.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 9
2
It looks like a fight of American English vs. British English. I'm American, and we would say 1b and 2b.
2
The past perfect is also used for actions that are considered to be finished or over. So whenever you use phrases such as 'the first time' or 'the second time' etc, while referring to a past event, you need to use the past perfect. These can only be done at one time, which means they don't span a longer time period. So the correct answer would be:
11b) I first played the guitar when I was a teenager.
For the second question, it gets a little trickier because technically you could also use the present continuous: "did you ever meet anyone famous while you were working in Hollywood?"When you work somewhere, it is generally understood that you did it for a longer period of time and so you could use the past continuous. This is generally used if the time period finished recently, for example if someone has just finished working in Hollywood and someone is asking about his time there. However, as this period of time is now clearly over, most native speakers would use 2b.
Hope this helps! :)
0
According to me:
1b) I played the guitar first time when I was a teenager..
2b) Did you ever meet anyone famous when you worked in hollywood?
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
