comma before "because"
I've written "Now I live in Moscow because I entered a university here." and I was told that I need a comma before "because".
The explanation was " If you lived in Moscow before for one reason, but now live there for another reason, you wouldn't need the comma. If you are just saying you live in a different place and the reason is A, then you need the comma."
and my brain exploded.
Are there any strict rules?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 3
2
My brain almost exploded too. I would say that it depends on context. In this case, we don't really need to know whether you've lived in Moscow before and if it was for the same reason as this time. It's just a minor detail. However, in some cases, it really does create a confusion, especially in negative sentences.
I don't love you, because you're poor = you have no money and that's why I don't love you
I don't love you because you're poor = I do love you, but the fact that you're poor has nothing to do with it
Usually, if you don't have a comma, it helps to have a longer sentence to clear up the ambiguity. For example: I don't love you because you're poor; I love you because you make me laugh.
0
http://wire.rutgers.edu/p_grammar_comma2.html
Here are my comments: Most of the time, you don't need a comma before "because" when the because-clause provides essential information.
Examples of essential information:
Now I live in Moscow because I am attending a university here.
I study languages because I like to learn about the culture of other countries.
You can use a comma before because in the following situations:
1. To set off non-essential or additional information
2. To break up a very long sentence
3. Sometimes when because comes after a negative sentence
Examples of #1
John explained to me the theory of relativity (this is the main idea)
Now we can add non-essential or additional information to that main idea, and we will use commas:
John explained to me, after conducting much research, the theory of relativity, because he was very interested in the subject.
If you delete ", after... research," and ", because he was interested", your main idea remains: John explained to me the theory of relativity.
---
In your example, your main idea is "Now I live in Moscow because I entered a uni here," therefore you don't need a comma.
I hope this helps!
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
