Search from various English teachers...
China flagXuanzi
Why people don't use "Sie" but "Es" in this sentence? The sentence is " Es sind gelbe Blumen" . Does "Es sind" means "They are" here? if it does, "Es" means "it", "Sie" means "They", that's why i don't understand why it's wrong to say "Sie sind". Anyone could help me with this? i'm a beginner to learn German. thanks a lot~!!! :)

Answers · 6

4
"Es sind" is an expression for "there are" which is used to say that something exists. In English you would say "there are yellow flowers." It is the same in German so don't look at this sentence as if the "Es" is a pronoun for the flowers. The difference would be: Es sind gelbe Blumen = There are yellow flowers (meaning there are yellow flowers here, they exist) Sie sind gelbe Blumen = They are yellow flowers (meaning the flowers are yellow) Was sehen Sie hier? Es sind gelbe Blumen! - What do you see here? There are yellow flowers! Welche Farbe hat die Blumen? Sie sind gelbe Blumen. - What color are the flowers? They are yellow flowers. I hope that clears it up for you. I'm not that great at speaking German either, but I'm pretty sure I understand enough to help you.
0
Please note that it is very uncommon to say "Sie sind gelbe Blumen." It would rather be like this. Question: "Welche Farbe haben die Blumen?" Answer: "Sie sind gelb."

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today