Search from various English teachers...
China flagMay
I have a question about sequence of tenses. Hope you can help me with it. Thanks. there is am example in my Grammar book about sequence of tenses: I had known Palmer, when this story starts, for nearly four years. I cannot figure out why here use “had known” and “starts”. why not "have known" and "starts" or "had known" and "started" ?

Answers · 3

0
The short answer is that you are correct. "Had known" and "started" would be correct, perfect grammar. In reality, people don't always use perfect grammar. This is true even for very educated native speakers. When a story is about the past it should be told in the past tense, but we often like to change a few verbs to the present. Why? Because we think the present tense can make the story sound more exciting, as if it's happening right now. This sort of use is not always taught in textbooks, but it is very common in conversation when people are telling a story. It's not perfect English, but it also isn't really considered very wrong. In writing, however, it would be better to avoid mixing up tenses like that. Hope this helps!
0
The author is talking about the time when the story starts. Imagine yourself at that time. Then you cannot use Story started. You have to use the story starts. Now, at that time which was in the past, you HAD known someone for some years because if you use HAVE known, you will be talking about the present time (but you are talking about the time when the story starts). I have explained what the author wants to say. Now if he wanted to convey something else, he can very well use "I had known Palmer, when this story started, for nearly four years". This is correct grammar, but is used in a different context. e.g. A. Tell me the story. B. I had known Palmer, when this story starts, for nearly four years. A. Did you know Palmer for long when this story started ? B. I had known Palmer, when this story started, for nearly four years.
0
See my answers on your 汉字写的 entry.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today