なります?します?どちらが 正しいですか?
加藤さんは 娘を デザイナーに (したい · なりたい )です。
どちらが 正しいですか?どうして?
哪个正确?为什么?这句话是“加藤想让女儿成为设计师。”对吗?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 8
2
加藤さんは、娘さんを デザイナーに したがっています。
Mr. Kato wants to make her daughter a designer.
There are couple of things you have to pay attention:
-「XはYになる」means "X becomes Y".
If you use 「なる」, the subject must be 「娘」.
加藤さんの娘さんは デザイナーになりたがっています。
Mr. Kato's daughter wants to be a designer.
In your sentence, the subject is 「加藤さん」.
-「XをYにする」means "make X (into) Y".
-~たいです is good only when you are talking about yourself (or asking someone about him/herself). To express 3rd person's mind, you have to use ~たがっている(~たがる+いる)or other indirect way.
-To make it polite, use「娘さん」instead of just 「娘」。
1
The answer is したい。
加藤さん=Mr. Kato
は=the case particle as a subject marker
娘=(his) daughter
を=a case particle as an object marker
デザイナー=a designer
に=the case particle for 'to', 'into', 'in' etc.
したい=する(=make) + ~たい(=an auxiliary verb for "want to~" "wish to~")
です= a copula
Literally it translates to "Mr. Kato wants to make her daughter a designer".
--------------------------------
なりたい = なる(=to be, to become) + ~~たい(=want to/wish to)
なりたい would be used to say:
Mr.Kato wants to be a designer. 加藤さんは、デザイナーになりたいです。or なりたがっています。
0
Neither. If you are not Mr.Kato's daughter you do use "-tai". I would use "-tegaru" meaning "appears to want". I use this because you don't really know if that person actually wants to. But I never use it with superiors, I just use a negative for them. (naru is better for this sentence)
加藤さんの娘はデザイナーをなりてがるです。(Mr.Kato's daughter appears to want to be a lawyer.)
加藤さんの娘はデザイナーをなりませんか? (Isn't Mr.Kato's daughter becoming a lawyer?)
I don't know if you were talking about his daughter, but that's what it sounds like.
0
したい 是 想做什么的意思,なりたい 是 想成为什么的意思,这样的话答案是后者
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
