Search from various English teachers...
Russia flagOleg
Will versus shall Will may be used for all persons, but shall can occur with I and we (according to some grammar textbooks) . Is shall still used in the future tense nowadays? I shall / will not do it. You can't make me. We shall / will find some other work for you to do. I'm sure that we shall / will have a good discussion. Why have I asked this question? I always try to apply the principle 'trust but verify'. There was a TV show in the channel "Culture", it was called "English in 16 Hours". And its host was Dmitry Petrov. He is a teacher, a polyglot (he is thought to know about 30 languages), a linguist, and a simultaneous interpreter. He said that the auxiliary verb 'shall' had not been used in English for 30 years. He told the audience to leave the English teachers if they taught their students or pupils that verb in the future tense because they did not know English at all.

Answers · 14

2
Yes - but it's formal and of a certain section of higher society. People who are more, "common" lower or middle class, would be more likely to say, "should" instead of, "shall". But yes it's used a lot and it's correct :) You shall use it :D
1
Nowadays the auxiliary verb "shall" is more often used in British English. It is less often used in American English. It is used in questions to ask one's opinion, especially in suggestions or offers. For ex: "Shall I read the text?"-asking for instructions "Shall I call him?" "Shall we help you?" "I've lost my keys. What shall I do?" "Shall" is often used with the 3-d person to refer to duties and obligations: For example: "The hirer shall be responsible for the maintenance of the vehicle" You can use the auxiliary "will" for all persons to express a future action.
0
I find "shall" very bookish and you never hear it in the US. We use "will" exclusively. "Shall" is used almost comedically: "Be sure to say hello to your family for me." -"I shall :)" Some British speakers may disagree with me, but I recommend that you not use "shall" in speech, opting for "will" and it's contractions.
0
"Shall" has a funny explanation in textbooks. The rule you give is OK for basic to intermediate speakers, but as you develop you will find "shall" is used more flexibly. I do agree that different speakers (eg. US/UK) use it in different degrees. You might like to read through this, though you'll see from the comments there is still some disagreement. Good luck, and I hope it doesn't confuse you: http://grammar.quickanddirtytips.com/shall-versus-will.aspx
0
@ Eire_Craig: But the native speaker and professional teacher Peachey does not agree with you, though I think I can use your advice speaking to an Irish person. Thanks a lot!

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today