English learners have some fun with this :)
"What did you bring that book that I don't like to be read to out of up for?"
Try to understand and, when you do, restructure this sentence in a way that demonstrates so.Alright, didn't get many answers, Aubépine's was best obviously :)
Here is a correct rephrase:
"What for did you bring up that book out of which I don't like to be read to?"
ty
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 34
1
There is no ( to ) after the word read , because the word ( to ) would require an indirect object .
Maybe we can write it like that = for what are you bringing up that book out of which I don't want to be read? right ??
0
Well, the "to" doesn't belong there.
0
Hm, Claire, you're right. But replacing it with 'why' would ruin the purpose of the question. 'For what' is indeed the best thing to do. Or even 'For what purpose did you ...'
0
I'm afraid that "What for" is always split when used in a larger sentence, Sertan. It's only unsplit when used in isolation.
"I am going to New York tomorrow." "What for?" or "What are you going for?" Interesting task, though. You could invert it and say "For what did you ..." but that is so archaic. It is better to replace it completely and use 'why'.
0
Wow! What a heated debate! I really can't understand why. Sertan, your sntence has no incorrect or unnecessary prepositions in it.
What FOR?
bring that book UP
I don't like to be read TO + I don't likt to be read to OUT OF that book
I hope I haven't missed any.
It is a perfectly grammatical sentence, just not worded in the clearest way (which is the point of your little game.)
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
