Search from various English teachers...
France flagAmbre
help in english Hello, I would like to know what is the difference between those two grammar in those sentences please : "I've eaten an apple" and "I ate an apple" Thank you!

Corrections · 4

0
"I have eaten an apple." refers to the action which does not state exact time, so we use present perfect. It is not "finished action" in the past. It can a mean e.g. "I have eaten an apple recently" but also "I have already eaten an apple" but also "I have eaten the whole apple and finished it" it depends on the situation. I ate an apple (e.g. yesterday). It means it is a past action which happened in the specific time in the past. We use past simple when we speak about something what is restricted as "finished action" usually with past time expressions (yesterday, last + months, years, days, ago etc.) Even if it is not stated in the sentence we know that we speak about the past, e.g. somebody asks: What did you eat yesterday? I ate an apple.
0
Hello,

I've eaten an apple = present perfect tense , we used this tense when we talk about action that is complete at the time of speaking ( no need in this tense to mention the time )

I ate an apple before one hour =

Past simple tense and we used it when we

Are talking about action completed

In specific time in the past .

Some examples:

I have seen this movie before .

I saw this movie last week .

I just have done my homework .

I did my homework yesterday .

I already have eaten an apple .

I ate an apple before one hour .

0
Michael, thank you for the link, oh no I am not a native English speaker aha, I am French, I changed my profile, it was a mistake! So tell me if I got it right, « I ate an apple » means that it’s in the past, it’s finished and that’s all whereas « I’ve eaten an apple » is a past action but which has an effect on the present, like for example if someone asks if I am hungry I can say  « I’ve eaten an apple, I’m fine thanks » ?
0
This might help you https://dictionary.cambridge.org/grammar/british-grammar/past/past-simple-or-present-perfect Although I see your profile appears to show native speaker English proficiency :)

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today