Search from various English teachers...
Japan flagwaterlily
What is the difference in usage between "in" and " of"? The population of China is larger than that of Japan. The lifespan in Japan is longer than that in China. I think the two sentences above are right. My question is whehter it is possible to change "in" to "of" in the setence. Please explain the difference in usage between "of" and "in". Thanks in advance.

Corrections · 6

0

What is the difference in usage between "in" and " of"?

A: The population of China is larger than that of Japan.
B: The lifespan in Japan is longer than that in China.

I think the two sentences above are right. My question is whether it is possible to change "in" to "of" in the sentence. Please explain the difference in usage between "of" and "in".

Thanks in advance.

=====================================

In my opinion, something does not seem right in sentence B — we are referring to the average lifespans of the Japanese and the Chinese. In other words, we are comparing the average lifespans of people from different countries, not the countries itself. 

Therefore, instead of using the preposition "in", it would be better to re-write sentence B as: "The average lifespan of the Japanese is longer than that of the Chinese." Here, we use the preposition "of" to indicate some reference or connection. For instance, "of" connects the phrase "average lifespan" to "the Japanese" while "of" connects the word "that" (which actually means "the average lifespan") to "the Chinese". 

We can use "in" but the meaning will change. If we modify sentence A slightly as shown below: 

C: The population of foreigners in China is larger than that in Japan. 

Now, we need the preposition "in" because we are referring to people found within a large area such as a province, prefecture, city, ward or country. However, we still need the preposition "of" as the word "population" is used in reference to "foreigners". 

I hope this helps you. 


0
Thank you. Your comment was really helpful.
0
The population of China is larger than that of Japan. <- correct The population in China is larger than that in Japan. <- raises a question in the listener's mind. I think once you really get the meaning of 'population' and 'lifespan' you'll know whether to use 'of' or 'in'. You may want to use English to English dictionary and see a lot of sentence examples to get the context. You're most welcome!
0
The first sentence is talking about China's population . The second sentence is not talking about Japan's lifespan but the lifespan of the people in Japan. Of and in cannot be switched in these sentences.

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today