Corrections · 7
"Spadework for a Palace" by László Krasznahorkai: - A Review
I'm not entirely sure if I liked this book or not. The style of the novel is really frustrating, even suffocating, as almost the whole book consists of a single sentence, an unedited, uncoordinated flow, of thoughts, of a deeply delusional and neurotic person, who corrects and contradicts himself in every single paragraph. That writing style made me feel like I was locked up in the narrator's head, which in this case is a rather "painful" experience.The book contains some philosophical thoughts on the role of catastrophes and destruction in human society and the role of artists, but for me, these argumentations/arguments were are not supported well enough. My impression was that those are more like statements, then than theories. As Krasznahorkai was described by Susan Sontag as the “contemporary Hungarian master of the apocalypse”, (British style: comma after the closing quotation mark; American style: comma inside the closing quotation mark) I can believe that this philosophy is a recurring element of his novels, but/yet I think that in this book it is not elaborated enough to give a consistent view of the theory. So, I think it is not optimal to start the Krasznahorkai oeuvre with this book (as I did); however, it is unquestionably a very well-written, imposing work.
Spadework for a Palace by László Krasznahorkai - A Review
I'm not entirely sure if I liked this book or not. The style of the novel is really frustrating, even suffocating, as almost the whole book consists of a single sentence: an unedited, uncoordinated flow, of thoughts, of by a deeply delusional and neurotic person, who corrects and contradicts himself in every single paragraph. That writing style made me feel like I was locked up in the narrator's head which, in this case, was [1] a rather "painful" experience.The book contains some philosophical thoughts on the role of catastrophes and destruction in human society and the role of artists; but for me, these arguments were not supported well enough. My impression was that those these are more like statements, than theories. As Krasznahorkai was described by Susan Sontag as the “contemporary Hungarian master of the apocalypse”, I can believe that this philosophy is a recurring element of his novels but I think that in this book, it is not elaborated enough to give a consistent view of the theory. So I think it is not optimal to start the Krasznahorkai's oeuvre with this book (as I did). [2] However it is unquestionably a very well written, imposing work.
1. You were describing feeling "locked up" (past), so this needs to be in the past too.
2. Better: "I don't think this book is a good {or: an optimal} introduction to Krasznahorkai's œuvre."
Excellent English, and kudos to you for tackling such an ambitious work! I'm not sure if this was the case with Sontag (since she was also a film critic), but a lot of us became interested in Krasznahorkai because of his collaborations with Béla Tarr, most notably, the epic Sátántangó. In that one, I think the waking dream, stream-of-consciousness style really works because it parallels the lives of the villagers who were also waking up from the "stupor" of the collapse of the Soviet Union and were stumbling through an uncertain future.
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
