Search from various English teachers...
United Kingdom flagSam Black
Urgent - Need help with English grammar! Hi guys! Here are two sentences: 'How long has Jeremy lived in England' 'What's the best book you have ever read?' I'm very confused about why has comes before 'Jeremy' but after 'you' ('has Jeremy' and 'you have'). Is it something to do with subjects and objects? Thank you!!

Corrections · 3

1

Urgent - Need help with English grammar!

Hi guys!

Here are two sentences:

'How long has Jeremy lived in England'

'What's the best book you have ever read?'

I'm very confused about why has comes before 'Jeremy' but after 'you' ('has Jeremy' and 'you have'). Is it something to do with subjects and objects?

Thank you!!


The easiest way to describe this is to rewrite the sentence adding an extra words that people often leave out when speaking, like this. I will also color the subjects and verbs of the sentences. 

'How long has Jeremy lived in England'

'What is the best book that you have ever read?'


Notice how in a simple question with one subject and verb that the verb comes first and subject second as in 'How long has Jeremy lived in England' and 'What is the best book ...?'

The reason that the 'you' comes before have in the second part is because it is a dependent clause, meaning it cannot stand alone as a sentence. 'that you have ever read' is not a complete sentence because it starts with 'that'. 

The example you gave is challenging because 'that' is not written in the sentence, but it is implied. 

I hope this answers your question!

-Nicholas


0
Try the tenses.

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today