toefl question 1
The article states that a Whistler’s new painting has been found. The painting is similar to the well known “Symphony in white” painting so it is attributed to the famous painter even if the work is not signed.
The article provides three reasons in support of its argument.
However, the professor explains that the argument made by the reading passage is not totally accurate. He then goes on to refute each of the author’s reasons.
First, the reading material claims that three years after Whistler’s death a friend of him organized an exibition in which this painting was included and the artist’s friend attribuited the painting to Whistler.
The professor refutes this point by saying that there is not real evidence that the painting was a Whistler’s work. The exibition was not only a show of his paintings, other painters’ works were included in the show.
Second, the article points out that the woman in the painting resembles the one of the “Symphony in white” because the style and the colours are similar. In fact,the two paintings have the same monocromatic palate.
However, the professor says that the painting could have been painted by lots of different painters at the same time. That woman was a popular model at that time, and the use of monocromatic colour was popular between painters as well.
Third, the reading passage states that Whistler didn’t always use his signature on his paintings. He often added a butterfly to his works and the painting has a little butterfly in the lower right corner.
The professor opposes this point by saying that the butterfly in the painting is not convincing, because it is different from Whistler’s butterly in shape and colour. Moreover, the artist used to add it to the upper left corner of his works. The butterfly we can see in the painting has probably been added after from someone else.
Search from various English teachers...
Corrections · 1
1
toefl question 1
The article states that a new Whistler painting has been found. The painting is similar to the well known “Symphony in White” painting so it is attributed to the famous painter even though the work is not signed.The article provides three reasons in support of its argument. (What article? Should you explain for the reader?)
However, the professor explains that the argument made by the reading passage (What reading passage? Should you explain for the reader?) is not totally accurate. He then goes on to refute each of the author’s reasons.
First, the reading material claims that three years after Whistler’s death a friend of his organized an exibition in which this painting was included, and the artist’s friend attributed the painting to Whistler.
The professor refutes (Disputes? Seeks to refute? It's only really refutes if you accept his argument I think.) this point by saying that there is no real evidence that the painting is (probably keep tenses consistent here) a Whistler.. The exibition was not a solo Whistler exhibition; other painters’ works were included (in the show you don't need this).
Second, the article points out that the woman in the painting resembles the one in the “Symphony in White” because the style and the colours are similar. In fact, the two paintings have the same monochromatic palate.
However, the professor says that the painting could have been painted by any of lots of different painters. The woman was a popular model at that time, and the use of monochromatic colour was popular with painters as well.
Third, the reading passage states that Whistler didn’t always sign his paintings. He often added a butterfly to his works, and the painting has a little butterfly in the lower right corner.
The professor opposes this point by saying that the butterfly in the painting is not convincing, because it is different from Whistler’s butterfly in shape and colour. Moreover, the artist used to add it to the upper left corner of his works. The butterfly we can see in the painting has probably been added later by someone else.
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
