Search from various English teachers...
Romania flagMary
HEY YOU! Yes, you! Please help me out! So, was studying seported speech at school when this example popped up: You must call me --> He insisted that I called him. (I don't remember the exact words, but it was something similar to that) When I looked it up on the internet, there was a blogger teacher who insisted upon the fact that this manner of reported speach is wrong, as it should be "He insisted that I call him" , since we use the subjunctive when reporting. (When I asked my teacher about it, he was in a hurry and wasn't very clear) If there is anybody willing to explain this to me in more detail and add some examples, I would be very thankful.

Corrections · 3

1
In the case of converting "You must call me" into a reported speech sentence with the same meaning, the subjunctive "He insisted that I call him" is the correct way to go.
1
There are two ways to interpret it. 1. "He insisted that I called him" is correct if the speaker means "I'm pretty sure I didn't call him, but he insisted that I did." So if that's what the speaker is trying to say, then "He insisted that I called him" is fine. 2. The subjunctive ("He insisted that I call him") is used to express ideas that are contrary to fact or, as in your case, when someone is giving a demand, order, request, or instruction. For example: He demanded (that) we be ready on time. We insist (that) you sit in the front seat. It is required that all students wear their uniforms. We request that he eat lunch first. With subjunctive, you just have to watch out for three things: 3rd person singular endings change (he eats alone--> We require that he eat alone) Was becomes Were (I was here--> If I were here) Am/is/are becomes "be" (I am here at 10-->They insist I be here at ten.) Hope this helps!
0
Thank you very much! Your answer has been very helpful!

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today