Search from various English teachers...
China flag佳佳林
Which one is the right sentence strictly? Arguing with my teacher 1. The difference between phone and PC ,however,was that the former, whose popularity was the highest,was in general more commonly used than the latter, which experienced a falling trend in application. 2. The difference between the application of phone and PC,however, was that the former, whose popularity was the highest, was in general more commonly used than the latter, which experienced a falling trend. ( it's a part of a description of a chart)

Corrections · 11

1

Which one is the right sentence strictly? Arguing A discussion (arguing is often used as 吵架),with my teacher

1. The One difference between phone and PC , however, was/is that the former (whose popularity was/is the greater highest) was in general more commonly used than the latter, which experienced a falling trend in application. (a difficult way to express a simple idea)

According to the graph, the PC is increasingly less popular than the modern smartphone (but they have different functionality of course).

2. The One difference between the phone application of phone and PC software, however, was that the former, whose popularity was the highest (were there three things compared?) , was in general more commonly used than the latter, which has experienced a falling trend.
( it's a part of a description of a chart)  you should include the chart


Sounds like an IELTS part 1 Writing test

0

Which one is the right sentence strictly? Arguing with my teacher

1. The difference between phone and PC, however, was that the former, whose popularity was the highest, was in general more commonly used than the latter, which experienced a falling trend in application.
2. The difference between the application of phone and PC, however, was that the former, whose popularity was the highest, was in general more commonly used than the latter, which experienced a falling trend.
( it's a part of a description of a chart)


Depends what you mean by 'the application'.  Both could be correct.

0
1. Phones were used more than PCs, and, PC usage fell.
0
I agree with Adam that the 2nd one seems to make more sense, but neither are easy to read. I don't know exactly what the use case is, but in an American business setting, brevity is key, so I would reword it something like this: The phone was highest in popularity and was in general more commonly used than the PC, which experienced a downward (or falling) trend.
0
I think it could be said that the first one is less clear than the second but, the second has some unnatural word choices. "the application of" seems unnatural to me. I could be wrong but, as a native English speaker something sounds off. How about a third option: The difference between phone and PC however, was that the former, was more commonly in use than the latter, which itself experienced a decrease in usage.

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today