Search from various English teachers...
Brazil flagPaulo Henrique
Inside Philosopher Why is it so difficult to express with words things I have in my mind all the time? It's like: inside I'm a philosopher; on the outside I'm just a listener. Being a listener is not a bad thing, but that's not how I usually imagine myself when with others - although I like listening to different points of view. I once read about the Spirit of the Stairs, or something like that. It's when your discussing or arguing with someone but you only create a good argument way after the discussion is over. So you think you would've beaten the other person's argument if only you had said that. It happens with everybody, I guess. The thing is, the world doesn't follow our scripts. That's why inside our minds we imagine ourselves being so critical and right about the things we're discussing, but when we face another person on the real life the scenario is different, the other person always has an argument we couldn't ever have predicted. That's evident, since we were discussing with ourselves we manage to create the arguments we believe right, as well as those arguments to contradict. Important to say that the objective of having an argument with other people is not to win. There's no winning. We'll never prove they're wrong, the same way they can't prove us wrong, specially when one is talking about politics, religion or how to do the right choice. People somehow know that already, that's why they might understand winning an argument as making the other person not having an answer for what you said. It's not like that. If someone can't contradict you, he's not necessarily wrong - neither you're right -, it just may be the Spirit mentioned above, it may just be a lack of study on the subject in question. So, discussions must be practiced. Of course there're those who seem to be born to have the power of speech, to convince other people, like a politician, a religious leader or people who work with laws; but it doesn't mean others can't learn it. It's also a matter of courage, some people may prefer listening to arguing because they fear contradictions or the refusal of others (not my case), also, some people appear to be masters on the subject they're talking just because of their body language and it sort of scares those who think they don't know enough to argue (maybe my case). Learning the act of discussion will not only help me on the academic field, but also inside my social circle.

Corrections · 1

0

Inside Philosopher

Why is it so difficult to express with words things I have in my mind all the time? It's like: inside I'm a philosopher; on the outside I'm just a listener. Being a listener is not a bad thing, but that's not how I usually imagine myself when with others - although I like listening to different points of view.

I once read about the Spirit of the Stairs, or something like that*. It's when your discussing or arguing with someone but you only create a good argument long after the discussion is over. So you think you would've beaten the other person's argument if only you had said that. It happens with everybody, I guess. The thing is, the world doesn't follow our scripts. That's why in our minds we imagine ourselves being so critical and right about the things we're discussing, but when we face another person in real life the scenario is different; the other person always has an argument we couldn't ever have predicted. That's evident, since when we were discussing with ourselves we managed to create the arguments we believe right, as well as those arguments to contradict.

It is Important to say that the objective of having an argument with other people is not to win. There's no winning. We'll never prove they're wrong, the same way they can't prove us wrong, especially when one is talking about politics, religion or how to make the right choice. People somehow know that already, that's why they might understand winning an argument as making the other person not having an answer for what you said. It's not like that. If someone can't contradict you, he's not necessarily wrong - neither you're right -, it just may be the Spirit mentioned above, it may just be a lack of study on the subject in question.

So, discussions must be practiced. Of course there** are those who seem to be born to have the power of speech, to convince other people, like a politician, a religious leader or people who work with laws; but it doesn't mean others can't learn it. It's also a matter of courage, some people may prefer listening to arguing because they fear contradictions or the disapproval of others (not my case), also, some people appear to be masters on the subject they're talking just because of their body language and it sort of scares that those who think they don't know enough to argue (maybe my case). Learning the art of discussion*** will not only help me on the academic field, but also inside my social circle.

*or, after-wit = l'Esprit de l'escalier

**as far as I know --there're--does not exist. If it does, it shouldn't

***or, rhetoric

Very well written! Please write out in full "there are", "it's, I'm, we'll,..." etc. They would be fine in a chatroom, but here, they make a dog's dinner of your essay, which was really rather good without them. They just jar with the content. Also, omitting the parentheses and several other asides would improve your style.

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today