Search from various English teachers...
Italy flagEric
Talking about... Crimes and justice: Jury of peers and judges (Part 2) "Do you have trial by jury in your country? Do you think it’s a good system? " Italy does not try anybody by a jury of peers: everybody is judged by professional judges but in some case the jury is made up of professional and non-professional judges. In these cases, “popular” judges (Giudici Popolari , where “popular” means “of the people”) cooperate with professional judges. This topic reminds me of a Franz Kafka’s novel I read, which is called “The trial”, where the main character wake up in the morning and he is arrested and accused of something he don’t know and he can’t understand (something the judges never say during the story). In my opinion, Kafka was trying to say that justice is for everybody, whereas law is owned by a handful of people who know it, make it and control it. I think that juries of peers are meant to represent common people in law and justice. In one hand, this is a good implementation of the democratic ideals, but in the other hand, are we sure that the judgment of the people is neutral? I mean, a person who has been accused of a crime is going to be judged and then, maybe, punished. A professional judge should be “neutral”, but he/she never can. There’s nothing universal in law: a law is a proposition which is necessary to establish a behaviour in a social group or in a whole society based on cultural shared values. So, the judges’ neutrality concerns with the values of their culture. In addition, law represents those who hold power and in my opinion they don’t do what they do for the general interest, but for theirs and for the people related to them. I’m just saying that in the most countries, politicians belong to well-off classes, to “business classes” (for instance) who keep on realizing politcs advantageous to the big economical groups, keeping on making wars, causing economical crisis etc. What about workers? What is your opinion about this topic?

Corrections · 3

0
In Portuguese, we call it "coisa julgada material".
0
Correcting my entry: the judgement occurs by peers, but they don't have legitimation to make the decision create a impositive force.
0
Eric, in my opinion, you should first consider that you are are dealing with a branch of law, which is the Penal Law, that is strictly connected to the legality principle. I guess this is the reason why the judgements, in Jury, should occur through professional judges, as in the countries that adopt the civil law system (note that the USA system is different) there's the natural judge principle, so, we can't just leave the imposition of a punishment in hands of the common people. Note that professional judges are designated to their public roles by public exams, available for everyone who has the graduation in Law. It is a democratic process. The trial respects constitutional principles - that happens in all countries that observe the neopositivism or neoconstitutionalism - and that those reflections are sensed in penal trial too. Concerning the subject about law being an instrument of the rich and the powerful to control me masses, I guess you are following a Marxist view. Althusser and Pachvkanis have the same point of view. :)

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today