Corrections · 27
Although this is not really a correction, I am posting it in the correction box because the comment box appears too limted in size.
The original posting by chinafan is about five months old, but I just discovered it today, in December, 2012, and would like to comment.
In the history of the United States, it is undeniable that the so-called Native Americans were not treated with justice. (I say "so-called Native Americans" because those peoples were not truly natives of America. They most probably came to the Americas from Asia. Probably a more accurate appellation would be "First Americans.")
However, it should be known that similar conquest and colonization have taken place throughout history and throughout the word. There are few places in the world today, including chinafan’s native Germany, which haven’t been populated, at least in part, by invaders. For example, vast Siberia was conquered and colonized by Russians from west of the Urals. Parts of China, as well as Tibet, have been colonized by ethnic Han Chinese. Almost all countries which we call "Arab" countries were invaded, conquered and colonized by Arabs proceeding from the Arabian Peninsula. Black Africans of Central-African Bantu descent invaded and conquered southern Africa from the lighter-skin Bushmen. These are just a few examples of historical conquests. There are many, many more.
"Native Americans" acted similarly for thousand of years before the arrival of Europeans in the New World. This is because Native Americans were not one homogenous people. Rather, they were divided into literally thousands of different tribes, with different customs, religions, and languages. They frequently invaded each other’s territories, conquered and reconquered each other, and took members of conquered tribes as slaves. Indeed, in numerous instances, when the Europeans arrived in America, the Indian tribe they found in a particular place had previously conquered that place from its prior inhabitants.
In short, history is replete with examples of one people conquering another. To shine the light on the United States, while ignoring similar events in the rest of the world, demonstrates prejudice against America, not a principled opposition to imperialism. I can only wonder if chinafan will write another essay calling upon the Russians to leave Siberia; all Arabs to return to the Arabian Peninsula; black Africans to return to Central Africa; and yes, the Chinese to leave large parts of present-day China, as well as Tibet.
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
