I was living vs I lived
how can I say this phrase correctly?
1. I was living in France last year then I moved to The US.
2. I lived in France last year then I moved to The US.
3. I have lived in France for a year then I moved to The US.
or is there a better way to say this?
Thank you
Search from various English teachers...
Corrections · 6
2
I was living vs I lived
how can I say this phrase correctly?
1. I was living in France last year then I moved to The US. Good
2. I lived in France last year then I moved to The US. Good
3. I have lived in France for a year then I moved to The US. Este suena un poco extraño, pero es comprensible.
or is there a better way to say this?
#1 y #2 son perfecto.
¡Buena suerte!
0
I was living vs I lived
how can I say this phrase correctly?
1. I was living in France last year then I moved to The US.
2. I lived in France last year then I moved to The US.
3. I have lived was living in France for a year then I moved to The US.
or is there a better way to say this?
Thank you
Nice work :)
0
1) Generally if you were doing a progressive action, like living, the next thing you say happens during that action; it doesn't end it...it can, but not as a general rule. So opt for option...
2)...which works, unlike...
3) "I have lived" implies you're still there. There are contexts in which it wouldn't, but this isn't one of them.
A better (albeit very marginally) way of saying that:
1) I was living in France until this year, when I moved to the US.
2) I lived in France for a year before moving to the US
3) I had lived in France for a year before moving to the US.
0
1st option is better. Other option should be: "I had live in France for a year then I moved to the US."
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
