Search from various English teachers...
Vietnam flagTri Nguyen
Please help me I read this sentence on Independent : She had fallen asleep alongside her cousins while a lock-in was underway downstairs. Why do they use past perfect tense (had fallen asleep), though there is " while" in this sentence?

Corrections · 3

0
Well, the past perfect is used when saying that an action was completed before something else. "While" can be used to indicate that in the time that action was happening something else was happening at the same time. The use of past perfect doesn't necessarily exclude the use of "while".

For example, I can also say: I had been studying while my mum cleaned the house right before my dad arrived.

The sentence implies that before my dad came home, I had been studying and my mother had been cleaning.

In your case, the sentence implies that the cousins fell asleep while the lock-in was taking place downstairs.
0
Well, the past perfect is used when saying that an action was completed before something else. "While" can be used to indicate that in the time that action was happening something else was happening at the same time. The use of past perfect doesn't necessarily exclude the use of "while". For example, I can also say: I had been studying while my mum cleaned the house right before my dad arrived. The sentence implies that before my dad came home, I had been studying and my mother had been cleaning. In your case, the sentence implies that the cousins fell asleep while the lock-in was taking place downstairs.

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today