Search from various English teachers...
Germany flagBritta Wunderlich
some sentences... Which sentences are correct? Or where is the difference? 1) Said that she had committed herself to music when she was a baby. She said that she committed herself to music when she was a baby. 2) I have been playing the piano since I was a little girl. I have played the piano since I was a little girl. 3) I pretty messed it up. I pretty much messed it up. I pretty much messed up. Synonyms... 1) Can you say "He had little real friends" instead of "He had few real friends"?

Corrections · 3

0
some sentences...

Which sentences are correct? Or where is the difference?

1)
Said that she had committed herself to music when she was a baby.
She said that she committed herself to music when she was a baby.

I'm going to assume the first sentence is a typo. You must have meant, "She said that she had committed herself to music when she was a baby." This is the correct version. You are reporting what she said to you, meaning her words must have been, "I committed myself to music when I was a baby." So, you must report with "had committed," not "committed."


2)
I have been playing the piano since I was a little girl.
I have played the piano since I was a little girl.

Since she still plays the piano, then the first one is correct, as the continuous (or progressive) tense indicates on-going actions.



3)
I pretty messed it up.
I pretty much messed it up.
I pretty much messed up.

I think within context, the second and third could be okay. The first is wrong.

Synonyms...
1) Can you say "He had little real friends" instead of "He had few real friends"?

"Little" modifies non-count nouns when you're talking about quantity. You can obviously have "little friends," but then you're talking size, not quantity. So, you need "He had few real friends," as "few" is used for count nouns, which, of course, "friends" is.
0
some sentences...

Which sentences are correct? Or where what is the difference?

1)
Said that she had committed herself to music when she was a baby.
She said that she committed herself has been playing music since she was a baby.
To be committed to something/doing something, is to make the decision to follow through with some sort of project. We cannot consider babies capable of making this sort of a decision, I wrote what I think you meant by this sentence.
2)
I have been playing the piano since I was a little girl.
I have played the piano since I was a little girl.
One needs to use the present perfect with words like for/since, because these words show that the action continues into the present.
3)
I pretty messed it up.
I pretty much messed it up.
I pretty much messed up.
I really messed it up. Pretty much is informal and has a meaning somewhat similar to almost.
Ex: With your extremist thoughts on community, you’re pretty much a communist aren't you?

Synonyms...
1) Can you say "He had little real friends" instead of "He had few real friends"?
No, little is related to size when it is used with countable nouns. When it is used with uncountable nouns ( water, milk, love, courage ect) it means an amount.
Ex: She had little milk in the fridge, not enough to make a cake.
0
1) The second sentence is correct. You cannot use "Said that she" in that order. 2) Both are correct, though the first one conveys more of a sense that you are still playing the piano now in the present. 3) The first one does not work, but the second and third one are correct. The second one conveys that you have messed SOMETHING up. i.e. you broke something or made something worse. The third one conveys that YOU messed up i.e. you did something wrong. 4) No, you cannot say "He had little real friends" if you want to mean the same thing as the second phrase. The first phrase is 'correct', but it means that he had friends that are both little and real. As opposed to large and make believe :)

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today