Doubts on the reading passage
The reading passage introduces three reasons which support Jane Austen is the subject of a painting: family's endorsement, similarity with the face in Cassandra's sketch, and style linked with Ozias Humphrey. However, the lecturer disagrees.
First of all, the lecturer opposes that permission given by Austen's family. Because she had been dead for almost 70 years when the portrait was used for edition, which indicates the fact that even her family members didn't see her face. Therefore, it's impossible for them to verify the validity of the portrait.
Furthermore, the lecturer raises questions about the portrait's subject. Instead of Jane, there's evidence showing it could be one of the relatives of her extensive family, especially it might be her teenage cousins and children who could resemble Jane well enough at that time.
Last but not least, the lecturer argues that the painting's connection with Ozias is only limited to style, while the other features are attributed to a later date. One of those proofs is that the black canvas was not sold in London until the age of that girl in the painting added 27, when Jane was no longer a young lady. Consequently, the last point of view in the reading passage doesn’t have a leg to stand on.
Search from various English teachers...
Corrections · 2
1
Doubts on the Reading Passage [In main titles always capitalize the first, last, and all important words.]
The reading passage introduces three reasons which support that Jane Austen is the subject of a painting: the family's endorsement, a/the similarity with the face in Cassandra's sketch, and the style is linked with that of Ozias Humphrey. However, the lecturer disagrees.First of all, the lecturer opposes that permission that was given by Austen's family. This is because she had been dead for almost 70 years when the portrait was used for that edition*, which indicates the fact that even those family members had never seen her face. Therefore, it's impossible for them to verify the validity of the portrait.
Furthermore, the lecturer raises questions about the portrait's subject. Instead of Jane, there's evidence showing it could be one of the relatives of her extensive family, especially one of her teenage cousins or children who could resemble Jane well enough at that time.
Last but not least, the lecturer argues that the painting's connection with Ozias is only limited to style, while the other features are attributed to a later date. One of those proofs is that the black canvas was not sold in London until 27 years after the age of that girl in the painting, when Jane was no longer a young lady. Consequently, the last point of view in the reading passage doesn’t have a leg to stand on.
[* I assume you are talking about a picture used in an edition of a book.]
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
