Search from various English teachers...
China flagGrace
TPO 34 Integrated Writing Task The passage introduces three possible reasons why sea cows went extinct. The lecture, however, refutes the three theories one by one and argues that there is another reason that caused the extinction. First of all, while the reading suggests over-hunting by local people as a possible cause, the population of native Siberian people, in fact, did not necessitate hunting that huge amount of sea cows. The lecturer points out that the sea cow was an enormous animal. They were 9 meters in length and 10 tons in weight, so one sea cow was enough to provide food for the natives for months. Secondly, the theory of ecological disturbance does not hold water because such disturbance could have triggered a big decline in other animals, not just kelp, the food source of sea cows. According to the fishing ships then, the professor says, there was not such a decline in other animals like whales, so the amount of kelp would be just fine and would not cause the extinction of sea cows. Finally, contrary to the belief in the text that the arrival of European fur traders probably brought about the extinction, 1700s had already seen a very small number of sea cows before those traders came to the island. Therefore, the ongoing dropping in the number might arise from other conditions.

Corrections · 1

0

TPO 34 Integrated Writing Task

The passage gives three possible reasons why sea cows became extinct. The lecture, however, refutes the three theories one by one and argues that there is another reason that caused the extinction.

First of all, while the reading suggests over-hunting by local people as a possible cause, the population of native Siberian people, in fact, did not necessitate hunting so many sea cows. The lecturer points out that the sea cow was an enormous animal. They were 9 meters in length and 10 tons in weight, so one sea cow was enough to provide food for the natives for months.

Secondly, the theory of ecological disturbance does not hold water because such disturbance would also have triggered a big decline in other animals, not just kelp, the food source of sea cows. According to the fishing ships then, the professor says, there was not such a decline in other animals like whales, so the amount of kelp would be just fine and would not cause the extinction of sea cows.

Finally, contrary to the belief in the text that the arrival of European fur traders probably brought about their extinction, the 1700s had already seen a very small number of sea cows before those traders came to the island. Therefore, the ongoing dropping in the number might have come from other conditions.

Very well written!

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today