Search from various English teachers...
Russia flagElina
Present Perfect vs Past Simple 1.Let's say the accident just happened and I want to ask my friend that is next to me:"Did you see that?"/"Have you seen that"? Which one is correct? 2. Another situation: it's snowing outside and I want to ask my roommate wether she saw (has seen?) what the weather like today. What tense do I have to use? PP or PS?

Corrections · 5

0

Present Perfect vs Past Simple

1. Let's say the accident just happened and I want to ask my friend that is next to me:"Did you see that?"/"Have you seen that"? This could also apply to any unusual event: A reindeer in a shopping centre; a fox entering a butchers ; a lightning strike splitting a tree etc
Which one is correct?
2. Another situation: it's snowing outside and I want to ask my roommate whether she saw (has seen?) what the weather like today. What tense do I have to use? PP or PS?

 

I would say "Did you see the forecast for today?"

If I was talking about a film, I might ask "Have you seen that?"

Den

 

0

Present Perfect vs Past Simple

1.Let's say the accident just happened and I want to ask my friend that is next to me:"Did you see that?"/"Have you seen that"?
Which one is correct?
2. Another situation: it's snowing outside and I want to ask my roommate wether she saw (has seen?) what the weather like today. What tense do I have to use? PP or PS?

 

1. I think "Did you see that?" more appropriate. the action/accident has occured before the time of speaking .

2. use present progressive/continues. i.e: is it snowing outside? we use present continues for action in progress at the time of speaking.

 

i suggest you to visit anglo link channel on youtube for more explanation on tenses.

good luck.

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today