Search from various English teachers...
China flagALan Kuo
I have to say Chinese young students are wasting their time learning English! I found that most common mistakes I made are what I learnt from textbooks. First one! How to answer 'How are you'. This is a typical greeting taught in our English Class in China. I do remember my teacher told us that we cana never use I am good. In stead, we can only use 'fine, to describe ourselves.So the only answer is I am fine. Nevetheless,I have been in Australia for 2 years, what i have heard is almost everyone says I am good. The only occasion where people say I am fine is when they at table and asked to the waiter or waitress whether want some more. I have no idea why we learn it like this. Anyone can expplain it for me?

Corrections · 5

0

I have to say Chinese young students are wasting their time learning English!

I found that the most common mistakes I made are what I learnt from textbooks.

First one! How to answer 'How are you?'.
This is a typical greeting taught in our English Class in China. I remember my teacher told us that we can never use, 'I am good'. Instead, we can only use 'fine' to describe ourselves. So the only answer is 'I am fine'. Nevetheless, I have been in Australia for 2 years, and what I have heard is almost everyone says, 'I am good'. The only occasion where people say, 'I am fine', is when they are at a table and asked by the waiter or waitress whether they want some more. I have no idea why we learn it like this. Can anyone explain it for me?

 

Apologies for the above minor corrections.  Regarding you're question, I can make a guess at why you were taught that way.  We normally use 'well' as an adverb, not an adjective.  'I'm well' is using it as an adjective, although what we really mean is 'I'm doing well' (here it's an adverb).  But when we speak we often miss out non-essential words.  So, 'I'm well' is normal, and grammatically correct if you just imagine another verb there, like 'doing'.  I normally say, 'I'm well', or 'I'm good'.  'Fine' doesn't sound positive enough to me.  It kind of sounds like I have troubles but don't want to share them (and the person is normally only asking out of politeness!).  In the UK we also use, 'I'm fine', or 'I'm OK', when someone offers us something that we don't want or need. 

"Do you want a cup of tea?"

"No, I'm fine thanks."

0
You could also answer "I'm well thank you."
0
Ur teacher has never been abroad before.Forgive her/him!
0
I just learned that if you say "fine", which means you don't want to talk about it any more, and that's why people seldom say that. This is what I know, but maybe it's wrong.

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today