GRE argument practice
The author of this proposal askes the city government to increase the yearly budget for riverside recreational facilities. However, the argument is largely based on unjustified, illogical assumptions which make the conclusion somewhat invalid.
First, the author cites the surveys according to which water sports are ranked to be Manson City residents' favorite recreational activities. Here it is assumed that the surveys are valid. However, this is not always true. For example, the surveys may provide insufficient options as, after all, we cannot list all the options of recreational activities in a survey. Therefore, the survey could possibly not reflect people's actual favorite recreational activity.
Then, the author quotes people’s complaining about the bad quality and smell of the Manson River, in order to show the necessity to clean up the water. This is reasonable. However, questionable assumptions come then as the author convinces that the clean-up will lead to the increasing use of the river for water sports. This is not valid. There is an unsound assumption that the water sports facilities will make more use of the Manson River's water if the water is clean. In fact, there may be other reasons for the low water use. For example, it may be due to some geographical reasons that the utilization of water is inefficient.
Also, a clean-up can not necessarily solve the odor and water quality problem for the river. The author here bases the argument on an assumption that increasing the budget will solve this problem. This is true in some cases. For example, the odor caused by industrial pollution can be controlled and solved by governmental measures, in which case a clean-up is reasonable. Similar to the previous rebuttal, there could be other reasons for this problem, such as geographical and biological factors that make the problem unable to be easily solved by just putting money into it.
Finally, even if the use of the river for the water sports would be increasing, this does not mean the government should invest more in the riverside recreational facilities. The author’s argument for more budget is possibly based on an assumption that the water sports facilities’ increasing use of water will lead to its increasing need for money. This assumption is not necessarily true.
In conclusion, the argument is invalid as it is based on unsound assumptions and contains logic flaws.
Search from various English teachers...
Corrections · 6
1
GRE argument practice
The author of this proposal askes the city government to increase the yearly budget for Riverside recreational facilities. However, the argument is largely based on unjustified, illogical assumptions which make the conclusion somewhat invalid.
First, the author cites the surveys according to which regarding which water sports are ranked to be Manson City residents' favorite recreational activities. Here it is assumed that the surveys are valid. However, this is not always true. For example, the surveys may provide insufficient options as, after all, we cannot list all the options of recreational activities in a survey. Therefore, the survey could possibly not reflect people's actual favorite recreational activity.
Then, the author quotes people’s complaining complaints about the bad quality and smell of the Manson River, in order to show the necessity to clean of cleaning up the water. This is reasonable. However, questionable assumptions come then as the author convinces However, this is a questionable assumption, as the author assumes that the clean-up will lead to the increased use of the river for water sports. This is not valid. There is an unsound assumption that the water sports facilities will make more use of the Manson River's water if the its water is clean. In fact, there may be other reasons for the low water use (better: local residents not using the river for receation). For example, it may be due to some geographical reasons that the utilization of water is inefficient. [Note: it's unclear what you mean by 'inefficient' here--do you mean that the river may be too shallow to boat on, etc? Inefficient utilization of water sounds to me like a problem with drought, drinking water, etc, rather than landscape.]
Also, a clean-up can not necessarily solve the odor and water quality problem for the river. The author here bases the argument on an assumption that increasing the budget will solve this problem. This is true in some cases. For example, the odor caused by industrial pollution can be controlled and solved by governmental measures, in which case a clean-up is reasonable. Similar to the previous rebuttal, But there could be other reasons for this problem, such as geographical and biological factors that make the problem unable to be easily solved (better: not easily solvable) by just putting money into it.
Finally, even if the use of the river for the water sports would be increasing were to increase, this does not mean the government should invest more in the riverside recreational facilities. The author’s argument for more budget is possibly based on an assumption that the water sports facilities’ increasing use of water will lead to its increasing need for money. This assumption is not necessarily true.
In conclusion, the argument is invalid as it is based on unsound assumptions and contains logic flaws.
0
Big thanks to anyone who is willing to help correct this piece of writing cuz I know it's really long lol.
0
Here is the question.
In surveys Mason City residents rank water sports (swimming, boating and fishing) among their favorite recreational activities. The Mason River flowing through the city is rarely used for these pursuits, however, and the city park department devotes little of its budget to maintaining riverside recreational facilities. For years there have been complaints from residents about the quality of the river's water and the river's smell. In response, the state has recently announced plans to clean up Mason River. Use of the river for water sports is therefore sure to increase. The city government should for that reason devote more money in this year's budget to riverside recreational facilities.
Write a response in which you examine the stated and/or unstated assumptions of the argument. Be sure to explain how the argument depends on the assumptions and what the implications are if the assumptions prove unwarranted.
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
