Search from various English teachers...
France flagYoup
quick question on 'in which' From the following sentence, why 'in which' is used instead of 'which'? Which verb is using in? I tried to find a phrase finishes with 'in' but I cannot find... claim (in)? imports (in)? Could someone let me know? Thank you. Following phrase came from English teacher from UK. This is supported by a recent study conducted at Oxford University, in which they claim that as China increasingly imports varieties of edible items from different countries via air transport, the level of carbon dioxide rises sharply and that, inevitably, more Chinese people are suffering from asthma.

Corrections · 7

2
This is a good question.
In the example sentence, "in which" means "in this recent study."
Some other examples:
"I watched a documentary last night, in which they talked about steroids in sports."
"I found the purse I had lost, in which I had left my keys."
"I opened the bag, in which I found the cookies."
You can imagine that "in" means "inside of" for this situation.
Does this help?

quick question on 'in which'

From the following sentence, why 'in which' is used instead of 'which'? Which verb is using in? I tried to find a phrase finishes with 'in' but I cannot find... claim (in)? imports (in)? Could someone let me know? Thank you. Following phrase came from English teacher from UK.

This is supported by a recent study conducted at Oxford University, in which they claim that as China increasingly imports varieties of edible items from different countries via air transport, the level of carbon dioxide rises sharply and that, inevitably, more Chinese people are suffering from asthma.
1
quick question on 'in which'

From the following sentence, why is 'in which' used instead of 'which'? Which verb is using "in"? I tried to find a phrase finishes with 'in' but I cannot find... claim (in)? imports (in)? Could someone let me know? Thank you. Following phrase came from English teacher from UK.

This is supported by a recent study conducted at Oxford University, (in this study) they claim that as China increasingly imports varieties of edible items from different countries via air transport, the level of carbon dioxide rises sharply and that, inevitably, more Chinese people are suffering from asthma.

"in which" is a common buzzword of academics, and no self-respecting collegiate essay would be complete without, maybe, five or six of them. I always hated it and replace the ugly thing with "where". Feel free to do the same, yourself. Nobody will notice.

The phrase, acting as a pronoun, does make good logical sense, though, as you can see from the () above.
0
Thank you very much both of you, it is crystal clear! In the study, the researchers claim ... is the original sentence, and it is transformed as This is supported by a recent study conducted at Oxford University, in which they claim ... I do appreciate!
0
I agree with seand465b: the teacher's sentence is good. There is a comma after "recent study at Oxford University", and then "in which" refers to this study. The teacher goes on to write that, in the study ("in which"), they (the researchers) claim certain findings. Of course you could rewrite this without the "in", but then the report would be the referent, the thing the "which" refers to, so you would need to change the verb so that it goes "which claims that". In any English formal or academic writing, this would be frownef on; people make claims, not documents - though in less formal writing or the newspapers you will find that kind of construction. I hope this helps.
0
"which" refers to the study. In the study they claim... For example, this is the room in which I watch TV Without "in" it wouldn't make sense, it would seem to be the direct object of "claim" this is the TV which I watch

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today