In other languages, exam levels follow a logical vocabulary progress:
1) greet, buy a sandwitch
2) buy a freshly-made sandwitch at a reasonable price
3) tell your friends why they should buy a sandwitch and not an ice-cream
etc etc
What is the logic behind the HSK levels?
I'm trying to take HSK2 and I find it very hard to make sense of the lists. They look totally random to me. There are no complete vocabulary groups, there are no topic units, there is no clear explanation of what the learning outcome is. If I had to learn chinese fast and get a certificate for professional reasons, I think I'd hate it.
I have enough time and dedication to learn more words than necessary for the HSK2, but I think people who have a tight schedule or are expected to handle business matters fast in chinese will find it a waste of time to study random lists of unrelated words.
I'd rather have an exam based on learning outcomes and practical use, not the number of isolated words one can master.

