I have groups there and for individuals skype's strengths are obvious: pronunciation, conversation and computer share; but so are its limits
Comments · 4
My teachers have always managed to teach me grammar and other complicated points on Skype, I don't understand what the limitations are.
Unless you're talking exclusively about groups, in which case I have no experience to share.
I agree with you. There are some definite benefits to using skype to learn a language, but also some major drawbacks. I have found that if you are trying to increase your language skills through simple conversation and listening comprehension one on one, skype is an excellent tool. If you are trying to practice grammar, work with a large group of people, or work with children however, a hands on approach and meeting face to face may be more beneficial. Student-teacher connections and understanding are very important in these areas. I have always found that when I am face to face with someone, communication is better. Not to mention the all too often occassion of trying to teach a specific aspect of a language and then the online connection breaks. That not only interrupts the flow of the lesson, but confuses the student and the teacher!
Group size is an obvious limit for Skype.
Also, if a group is repeating something read or spoken by the person leading the group, the voices are not all in harmony. People say words out of sequence with each other. It still works for a repetition of anatomical terms, even though at most, I can understand what 3 students are saying. Even so, as long as they understand what I say, and we repeat a difficult word 2 or 3 times, Skype is an effective tool.
The fact that one native speaker is present to help with pronunciation makes it worlthwhile.
I think that so long as the group host shows a written text for all students to follow and/or discuss,
Skype is very effective within its limits.
As for children, I tutor a 5 year old but limit his lessons to 20 minutes at the most.
I tutor a 7 year old beginner, and seldom go beyond 1/2 an hour for those readings.
Older Children about 11 to 13 years old can be taught for a full hour if they are beyond a beginner stage. Some teens already study lots of English songs on their own, so that their English can be more advanced than the English of some adults who do not follow popular music.
One on one lessons on Skype can be more effective for the student, but groups are convenient for the variety of spoken language for the students.
Samantha thank you for your wise and judicious comments.
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
