Search from various English teachers...
Iran flagKhosro
Polite Behaviour and Rude Behavior

Is it rude to ask people about their jobs or their educations in the first meeting?

Do you think it's depend on situation?

Do you feel well if a stranger ask you about your job or your educations?

Which questions make you nervous in formal occasions?

 

Comments · 31

4

I think it is one of the common things to ask when first meeting or chatting to someone. You could say,
Can you tell me what you do please? Can you tell me about your job or what you are studying?
Yes sometimes it is more awkward if the person is not working or studying, therefore asking them what they do can be a more general things to ask.
More specific questions could be;
Do you work in an office? Do you go to university? What is your major? What are you majoring in? Do you enjoy your job or what you are studying? What else would you like to do?

Please could you explain this - in a formal traditional English party - I am not sure what this means :)
Best wishes Gillian

2

I think that most people have a pretty good idea of what is polite in their own culture, but when talking to someone from a different culture, it makes sense to err on the side of caution and not ask any such questions. 

2

It depends whether it's the 'real world', as opposed to the artificial context of language learning.

In the language learning context - especially if the linguistic level is low - it probably is acceptable to ask such questions. You tend to put aside normal conventions in the language learning situation, whether in a classroom or online.

In the real world, however, I would never ask a stranger, colleague or casual acquantaintance about their marital status or personal/family relationships. I would always wait to pick up on clues which they leave - I'd wait for them to mention a husband, wife, partner etc. If they didn't make any mention of 'a significant other' I would presume that there didn't have one or that they didn't want to talk about their situation. 

2

Personally, I don't like it when someone asks me any of those questions. I am gregarious and will TELL them all those things when we get close. To me, when a person has to resort to such mundane and canned questions, it denotes a lack of creativity and intelligence and perceptive ability on their part. It's a big turn-off for me. Can't you come up with anything interesting to say that will draw me in? 

 

Once we are deep into conversation and friendship and there comes a time where the subject comes up naturally, then it can be an appropriate question... but not until then. 

 

I should add that I'm probably not a "typical" American. I don't really want to have conversations with people who aren't creative. It's not a matter of language ability either. I've had people here send me first messages that were basic English with bad grammar that were still very interesting and made me want to know them better. If someone starts grilling me immediately, honestly, I might answer their question, sometimes, but then I will want to escape their company. 

 

At the least, isn't it better to come up with something more interesting to say or ask? 

2

Yes I would never ask about their salary or how much money they earn, this would be too personal to ask.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today