If I am a beginner or low-intermediate, I don't find it necessary to have a native speaker as a tutor. It's a myth, I am a tutor myself and I've got students that I would highly trust them to teach Portuguese for beginners or low-intermediate students.
Price is definitely what touches me. Sometimes I find tutors here to be extremely expensive but it's totally their right to set prices like those. But unfortunately I cannot afford to have sessions with them. But for certain languages like German, I have no choice. There are very few tutors for German and they're mostly above the 100 ITC price and soon or later they end up charging more so I just have to deal with it. Other languages offer good tutors for good prices.
Good reviews and ratings! Wow, that's important. Another thing that I check is if students are going back to this tutor, many people have hundreds of students but never regular ones and I don't find it attractive at all.
Recommendations are also part of the process when I choose a tutor.
Appearance and sex do not play a role in my decision! It's irrelevant!