Search from various English teachers...
China flagxiaokaoy
Do you think that "给我..." is interchangeable with "把...给我"?

As far as I know, "give sb sth" is interchangeable with "give sth to sb" in English, except for "give it to me" --- No one says "give me it".

Comments · 4

0

@xiaokaoy:

You are right, people don't say "give me it," but I have certainly heard people say "give me that/this/the money/etc."

 

0

To Jmat:

...帮助你英语 and ... 把英语帮助你
...表达他们想法 and ...把想法表达他们

Only one of those four phrases is grammatically correct. It's 表达他们想法, which means "express their thoughts".

 

I started this discussion just because I wanted to know whether there were any learners of Chinese who knew that "给我..." and "把...给我" are NEVER interchangeable. Since so far I've found nobody who knows that, I have just written a notebook entry about his question. http://www.italki.com/entry/362231

0

This is interesting for me as a Mandarin learner.

给我它

把它给我.

From what I understood before, 把 moves a verb after its object. 

So is "verb sb sth" just a rule for 给 and select few verbs (like in English), or is it a general rule?

And if it is a rule, can 把 always be used to make it more natural?

 

For example, can I say...:

 

...帮助你英语 and ... 把英语帮助你

...表达他们想法 and ...把想法表达他们

 

...or did I just invent a rule that doesn't exist?

0

”给我... ”is interchangeable with "把...给我“, except for "给我它” .

In China, we also don't say “给我它”,we say“把它给我".

On this point, the expression of Chinese and English is the same.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today