Search from various English teachers...
Portugal flagAgostinho Carvalheir
Challenges I
Who is the criminal?

It was concluded that one of 4 men: Abel, Alberto, Carlos and Daniel, had committed a crime. The suspects made the following statements:
Abel: “Alberto committed the crime”
Alberto: “Daniel committed the crime”
Carlos: “I didn't commit the crime”
Daniel: “Alberto lied when he said it was me”
Knowing that only one of the statements is true, who is the criminal?

Comments · 5

0

Hello John, you are right. Sorry for my English. Carlos said: "I didn't commit the crime", and the criminal was exactly him.
Thanks for your tips.
0
Hello John and Soyuzbek, when indicating the criminal, this has to imply: 3 people are lying and only one truth ..

Yes or to find the truth teller or the three liars; we can imply assume that possibly the liars or one or two of them are telling an inverted lie. Which could be Carlos who was not there.
0
Hello John and Soyuzbek, when indicating the criminal, this has to imply: 3 people are lying and only one truth ..

0
we must assume one by one fur times for each man that they are telling the truth and then see if the other three men's statements confirmed or contradict.
A. If Abel tells truth; then Alberto contradicts and says to was Daniel. but Daniel says it was a lie from Alberto, and Carlos didn't go. possible because Carlos did not go and Abel's statement is holding up. So far.

B If Alberto tells the truth then Carlos did not go and Abel is saying it was Daniel and Daniel is confirming that Alberto is not lying when incriminating himself Daniel..

C If lCarlos is telling the truth, then he Carlos did not go. Daniel says Alberto is lying about him. and Alberto must be lying as Daniel says. so Abel is correct. Alberto committed the crime.

D If Daniel is telling the truth then Alberto is lying about him and Carlos did not go and abel is telling the truth.

Alberto I think committed the crime.
After questioning Daniel and Alberto one more time.
0
So, let me try to catch the criminal.

If it is supposed only Abel talked true, we can realize that Alberto had lied. It is mean that Daniel was correct. Finally, we can't accept Abel's statement as true.

If we accepted that only Alberto talked true, it is clear Abel was incorrect. Carlos saying nothing related to our topic ;). We should conclude Daniel is lying, and make conclusion that Danial is the crime.

I wait response from you. Am I right? if not, why?

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today