Search from various English teachers...
China flagJerry
What's the right rising tone in a yes/no question with the ending 'with me?'
How to speak these 2 sentences? (Cause they have same type, the ending is 'prep.+ pron.')

Will you go to park with me?   
Will you go there with me?

I found different tone with them, which one is right? why?

https://youtu.be/mJXlSR7X_8k?t=175   
https://youtu.be/GqpC3aP_6qg?t=598  
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k6_1r52WplI&feature=youtu.be&t=906  
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bbWJ1gtJvcY&feature=youtu.be&t=1368 

I don't know how to add comment behind the answer. So this is my question, according the rules, the rising tone is starting on the stress syllable of the last content word. but I can bypass the rule, and move it according the emphasized word? is it normal to move the rising tone on the function word?

Comments · 5

1
That depends. The main tone needs to go on whatever word you want to emphasize — the one that gives new information. Without taking the time to listen to all those recordings, I’d say that in your first sentence, “park” is probably the most important word, so it would probably get the tone. For your second sentence, it would depend on the conversation.


Will you go there with me?
The speaker is thinking "I’m not sure if you will or won’t. Perhaps I doubt you will."

Will you go there with me?
You or someone else?

Will you go there with me?
Emphasizes the going, as opposed to, for example, just talking about it.

Will you go there with me?
There, as opposed to some other place.

Will you go there with me?
Or will we go separately?

Will you go there with me?
Or will you go with someone else?
1
Rising tones or stressed words create emphasis in English, without changing the basic meaning of the sentence.

So in your first example, the speaker emphasises the verb (come -- emphasising that the question is about coming, as opposed to any other action); in the second example, the speaker emphasises the question of whether the people are coming specifically with him -- so he's emphasising the question of accompaniment. In the third, Obama stresses me — you might do this to express surprise that "you guys" have chosen to come with me, of all people.

I hope this helps! Feel free to write to me or book a meeting if you have any further questions :)
0
Yes, standard emphasis means the main tone goes on the last content word, but we can stress any word we want for emphasis. Yes, we can even stress a function word if we need to. For example:
A: Would you like milk (rising ton), or sugar (falling tone)? (A choice question)

B: I’d like milk.

C: I’d like milk and sugar. (Emphasizing that C would like both.)



Scenario 2:
A: Would you like milk or sugar (rising tone)? (A yes-no question)

B: Yes, I would :)

C: No, that’s OK (meaning I wouldn’t like any milk or sugar). Thank you.
0
any hint else, thanks!
0
Depending on the context and also the country, it can sound different! As an American, I think the last video sounds the most natural but in a country like England, for example, the tone will sound different. In my opinion, the tone should start lower in the beginning of the sentence and end higher. I hope this helps!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today