It would absolutely depend on my goals.
If I'm learning a language for fun, just to communicate with native speakers, then I would opt for having a lesson with a non-qualified native speaker, mostly because it's cheaper, but still good enough.
If I study a language because I would like to move to a new country, where I have to solve my official things in the country's national language, then I would choose to book lessons with a qualified teacher, because they likely have some experience with teaching people, and they also had to learn those things they teach. While a native speaker might not be able to explain why something is said in a particular way, a qualified teacher likely is capable of doing it.
I also think that it depends on your skills in the language. If you're a total beginner, I think an unqualified native speaker can help just as much as a teacher. If you're more advanced, a teacher can generally teach you more, in my opinion.