Short answer, Batman.
Long answer...
Speaking for myself alone, superheros and villains are interesting because they help us work out morality. They provide the narratives by which we explore our beliefs in regards to what is right and wrong. The powers are secondary. Superman represents Virtue Ethics. He doesn't strive to be good, he IS good. He embodies virtue, he doesn't struggle to do the right thing. His history is a reflection of the Christ story. He comes from a different world, sent by his father, he is in many ways omnipotent. In other words, he's incredibly boring. (No offense 'S' lovers!)
Batman does not represent virtue. He is a flawed human being who's powers come from technology and his indomitable will. Batman represents Deontological Ethics. He believes he is acting morally when he's acting within a framework of rules (which he constantly struggles with). Batman is interesting because his stories recognize the power of consequence. The entire series is a consequence of one thief's act on one night, in a Gotham back lane. Superman doesn't really initiate consequence, he IS the consequence. Batman's villains are equally interesting. In the modern retelling, Joker (who is a consequence of Batman) isn't motivated by money or traditional centers of power or even revenge (unlike Penguin). Joker exists to call out, what he thinks is, the hypocrisy of Batman. If Batman is allowed to construct a Deontological system of rules by which he judges morality, why then cannot every individual do the same? And when they do, who is to say they are wrong? Joker is Jung's Shadow, or more accurately, the Shadow of the comic book reader or movie watcher. Batman is the cage which controls the Shadow. He's there to remind us that rules matter and they are not arbitrary or selfish, but we must be careful on how we construct them.
Also, his car and cave are really really cool.