Search from various English teachers...
United Kingdom flagLa Liseuse
A message for new teachers and community tutors
Let's start with a question. Imagine yourself in this situation:

Imagine you're a tourist, just arrived in a strange town. You need to find your hotel, so you ask a friendly-looking passerby for directions. All you want is to be told "It's the second street on the right" and then you can go on your way.

But then suddenly someone rushes up to you trying to sell you a map of the city. Someone else barges in and tries to sign you up for an expensive guided tour.

How would you feel? Not good, I suspect. You ask a simple question and suddenly the vultures descend, trying to make money out of you. If you don't speak the local language well, you might not even realise it at first. You might mistake the opportunistic tour guide, out to make a quick buck, for a well-meaning passerby who genuinely wants to help.

Getting the picture?

By all means, answer learners' questions and build up a reputation as a helpful and reliable language resource, but please don't use the community pages as advertising space. It's a fairly crass thing to do, and the community here takes a dim view of it.

Comments · 141

22
It's been a while since I've used Italki much, but I decided to check back today, and ended up reading through this thread. I have to say that, at least from an outside viewpoint, it mostly just looks like a long and very petty argument between two parties, SHL and Alice, who both just keep fanning the flames. My comment probably won't help either, but here are my two cents.

@Alice - The main reason why you get more flack than other people on Italki is not *just* because you promote your services quite a bit, but because you also don't have a good command of English. You're promoting yourself in a position for which many people feel you are unqualified. When you claim that you shouldn't need to understand even basic English grammar because you're "just a tutor," you're implying that tutors are not real teachers, and don't need any special skills. Many tutors here are highly skilled and educated. And although it's true that casual English is also useful for many learners, most educated professionals know how to speak casually, too. I'm not saying you should stop tutoring or promoting, by the way. I'm just explaining *why* people single you out for criticism. Most other teachers either do less promotion or appear more competent. Or both.

@SHL - I agree with Andreas: although you've made several good points, you've also been relentlessly attacking Alice all throughout this thread. You've made irrelevant, sarcastic comments about her dog numerous times (and not just here). You pretend that you can't even understand her writing because of grammar mistakes, and you sometimes call her out on "mistakes" that aren't even mistakes (such as capitalizing the names of Italki's community boards, or using "they" as the pronoun for a person whose gender one doesn't know). And from what I've seen, you seem to be stalking Alice in other threads, too, just to make snide comments about her. Regardless of her qualifications to be a tutor, this is 100% high school bullying behavior.
16
@SHL

1) I see you've edited your comment several times. The original comment simply said "Oh Gray. Pleeeese. Stay in Phoenix, someplace I’d sure never go. Cry me a river." In addition to adding to your comment to make it (slightly) less rude, you seem to have now realized that I'm not in Phoenix, but rather in Austin. It makes sense that you've edited accordingly, but I notice that you didn't change anything else about the sentence -- it simply trashes on Austin rather than on Phoenix now, as though the two cities are interchangeable and equally worthless. Just as a general observation, this seems like exceptionally bad form for interacting on a forum where people aim to share both language and culture.

2) Since "Discussions" is the name of the board, I think it reasonable to treat it as a proper name, and to capitalize it as one would capitalize (e.g.) "Best Actor award." It is also reasonable to treat "discussion" simply as an adjective describing the function of the board, with no capitalization. I agree that one should be consistent, but it's hardly an egregious error.

3) "What, are we capitalizing every noun now like in German?"

Well, "discussion" here is functioning as an adjective (modifying "board"), not a noun. So no.

4) I never called out Alice for not saying him or her like I do. Nonsense. I’ve never done that.

You're right, you did not call Alice out on "he/she" vs. "they" in *this* thread. It was in another thread: https://www.italki.com/discussion/226705, where you wrote: 

"What is „they“ supposed to mean in that sentence, or to whom does it refer? I’m a man. That’s singular. Shouldn’t it have been...“he is not a big fan of the USA“ ? Then you said, „They explained this further yesterday.“ To which plural group of people were you referring? I’m confused by this use of language."

In any case, my intention in commenting wasn't to keep the argument going, but to point out the problems on both sides. This will be my last comment in this thread.
16
@Phil 
That's the cruel thing about this kind of bullying. It's almost invisible unless it's yourself that's affected. SHL has systematically targeted Alice through several posts, over several discussions, and talked down to her every step of the way. As I said, this isn't about ONE single comment, but the sum of them.
15
@SHL
I think you better calm down now. I think your comments towards Alice are borderline bullying, if not straight out bullying.
Maybe not one individual comment, but the sum of them.

https://support.italki.com/hc/en-us/articles/206353468-The-italki-Community-Guidelines
15
Alice, it is admirable that you want to help English language learners. But as you are aware that you do make many grammatical mistakes or are not careful to avoid them, it might be a good idea to indicate on your profile that you use a more informal/ casual style of English.

Many people here are trying to learn a standard form of their target language for exams like Ielts. If by chance these are people that you want to help, you might concentrate on improving your usage of standard English.

One particular word that you use would keep me from recommending you to any of my students: gonna. If it is your style, that's fine if learners are aware of it. If not, you can change your own speech patterns. People like Su.Ki who model a formal standard of writing didn't acquire those skills or language level overnight. It takes a lot of work and practice.

By the way, Su.Ki has been here on italki for years. She was highly respected five years ago when I was a regular here (different account that I can't access anymore). I've learned quite a bit from her including how to be more tactful, precise, and patient.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today