Search from various English teachers...
[Deleted]
A Question for English Linguists or anyone whose English skills are more sophisticated than mine
Today I heard a podcast that described an English grammar rule, however, I don’t think it should called a rule. Instead, I think it should be called a convention (a way of understanding or doing something that is generally accepted as correct, but not necessarily absolute (my definition)).

I wanted to be sure that the term convention was the appropriate term, so I looked up the definition of the term.
I found the following article written by a linguist from South Africa.

Setting aside the actual meaning of the term convention, I want to know if anyone can truly comprehend what the article is saying.
After reading the article, I could only think: What the _____ ?  

Does anyone honestly believe that they understand everything written in this article?
And I thought my understanding of the English language wasn’t all that bad, but… 

*************************************************************************************************


Research Article
Knowing linguistic conventions
Carin Robinson

Abstract

A linguistic convention is a principle or norm that has been adopted by a person or linguistic community about how to use, and therefore what the meaning is of, a specific term. Examples of such norms or principles are those expressed by propositions that express the laws of logic or those that express implicit definitions.

Arguments about the epistemic status of linguistic conventions, very broadly, fall into two camps: the one holds that the basis of linguistic conventions is objective and that, therefore, such conventions are genuinely truth-bearing. Knowledge of such conventions is therefore knowledge of the objective truth of such conventions. This camp might be labelled ‘realist’.

The other holds that there is no known basis to linguistic conventions and that conventions are, to the best of our knowledge, not objective, but invented. Their truth is stipulated by the relevant speaker or linguistic community. Such truth is, consequently, trivial and knowledge of such conventions simply knowledge of the stipulation. This camp might be labelled ‘anti-realist’. These are three standard accounts of the epistemic status of linguistic conventions, which all play into the first camp: (1) knowledge by intuition, (2) inferential a priori knowledge and (3) a posteriori knowledge. I give reasons why these accounts should be rejected.

I then argue that linguistic conventions, if conceived of as trivial truths, are knowable non-inferentially a priori. Such an epistemic account provides support for the second camp. In this regard, I marshal support from some recent work by Wright and Hale.

***********************************************

I wonder if I can find a copy of this article that's written in English :)
I think I like my definition of "convention" better... :)
My head won't stop spinning... :)


Comments · 23

6
I’ll take D - Klingon, Chris.

This issue is really common in academic writing. If the ideas aren’t novel enough, write in a highly opaque style that makes it hard enough to understand that people assume there must be something worthwhile in it. I think it comes from the publish or perish pressures of academia.
6
Jargonized version: The omnipotent sentient entity is my internal external regulatory mechanism. My viscerogenic necessities and propensities shall be catered to in all possible circumstances.

Meaning: The Lord is my Shepherd. I shall not want.

This is a similar case, regrettably quite common in academic papers or abstracts. I suppose all it's saying is this: certain words and expressions, though technically belonging to the same language, may have different meanings or connotations in different regions or countries, and none can be said to be more correct than the other.

In other words, this is a very complicated way of saying that languages are generally not absolute, but relative in normal use. This naturally excludes mathematical, scientific, programming or other such languages.
5
In "Politics and the English Language," George Orwell wrote:

Here is a well-known verse from Ecclesiastes:

"I returned and saw under the sun, that the race is not to the swift, nor the battle to the strong, neither yet bread to the wise, nor yet riches to men of understanding, nor yet favour to men of skill; but time and chance happeneth to them all."

Here it is in modern English:

"Objective considerations of contemporary phenomena compel the conclusion that success or failure in competitive activities exhibits no tendency to be commensurate with innate capacity, but that a considerable element of the unpredictable must invariably be taken into account."
5
I normally feel that people who resort to using Latin to bolster their arguments lack the "brights" to explain things in English.
5
I don’t find the language of this excerpt particularly opaque or inaccessible. It’s actually written in a simple style as far as academic writing is concerned. I have an undergraduate-level education in philosophy and found it easy to follow. But it is an academic paper, so it’s not written for laypeople.

epistemic: related to epistemology, which is the philosophy of knowledge. This paper looks into the epistemic source of linguistic conventions, i.e. where knowledge of linguistic conventions comes from.

a posteriori: knowledge derived from observation. A posteriori knowledge is limited in its objectivity due to human factors, whether sensory or social and environmental.

a priori: knowledge derived from reasoning. It’s believed that a priori knowledge is universal and objective.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today